Personality and accident proneness Summary

Topic

Study

Detail

Evaluation

Application

 

 

1.      Risk takers

2.      Risk avoiders

 

 

 

Injury-prone personality

Pitts, 1996

Predictors:

1.      Aggression

2.      Over-activity

3.      Boys are three times more likely to have an injury-prone personality

4.      Jaquess and Finney (1994) economic deprivation

 

 

 

Pheasant (1991)

1.      Personal characteristics

2.      Transient states

 

 

 

Freud

‘The Psychopathology of Everyday Life’ (1901).

 

 

 

Menninger (1938),

Unconscious wish to punish ourselves

 

 

 

Reason, 2000

Person approach

 

 

 

Greenwood and Woods (1919)

Accident-prone

·        Different levels of risk run by people in different jobs

·        Adelstein 1952 railway shunters

 

REPEATERS

Hill and Inst (1962)

Accident repeaters

Photographic process plant

Castle, 1956

 

ALCOHOL AND SUBSTANCE ABUSE

Simpson et a/. 2001).

Emergency departments in Scotland

 

 

 

Barbone et aI. (1998)

Medical records of drivers in Scotland

 

 

Personality and Road Accidents

Iversen,-Hilde; Rundmo,-Torbjoern 2002

Relationships between personality, risky driving and involvement in accidents

 

 

 

Ulleberg,-Pal  2001

Personality subtypes of 2,524 young drivers

 

 

 

Lajunen,-Timo  2001

Relationship between extraversion, neuroticism and psychoticism, and road traffic fatalities

 

 

LACK OF SLEEP

Asken, 1983

·        Make more errors

·        Need longer to complete a task

 

 

 

Maycock, 1996

Survey of 4,600 UK drivers found that 29 per cent admitted to having felt close to falling asleep at the wheel during the previous 12 months

 

 

TYPE A BEHAVIOUR PATTERN

Suls et al., 1988

More likely to have accidents

 

 

 

Magnavita, 1997

Drivers with the Type A behaviours had a greater risk of traffic accidents.

 

 

Jones and Wuebker (1988)

Personnel inventory

INTROVERSION AND EXTROVERSION

Liao et al., 2001

171 fire-fighters

 

 

 

Furnham and Heaven, 1999

Car accidents

 

 

 

Cellar et al 2001

Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PI-R) and self-report measures of prior workplace accident involvement

 

 

AGE

 

 

 

 

PROBLEMS WITH THE PERSON APPROACH

(Reason, 1990).

Chernobyl

 

 

 

(Reason, 2000).

·   Best people who make the worst mistakes

·   Mishaps are not random